Blog Layout
Can Protz be applied retroactively?
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued its Decision in Dana Holding v. WCAB (Smuck), applying its Protz ruling retroactively.
On June 16, 2020, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued its decision in Dana Holding Corporation v. WCAB (Smuck). In Dana Holding, the Court addressed the issue of the retroactivity of the Protz v. WCAB (Derry Area School District)
holding in the case at hand. The Defendant/Employer in Dana Holding
had filed an Appeal seeking a clarification as to when new law should be applied retroactively. The Court agreed to hear the Appeal, but on a limited basis, specifically, whether the retroactivity of the Protz
ruling should begin on the date of the IRE or the date of the decision.
Ultimately, the Supreme Court affirmed the Commonwealth Court’s holding that the retroactivity of the Protz
decision dates back to the date of the IRE.
In rendering its Decision, the Supreme Court reviewed the law in various other states and federal districts. The Court noted that there are initially two (2) scenarios when new law is issued: (1) cases that are actively in litigation and the issue(s) is/are preserved throughout the litigation; or (2) applying new law to cases that have become final. Each scenario presents with different results. In Dana Holding, the Court only addressed scenario number 1. As such, the Supreme Court has not addressed scenario number 2.
After reviewing the prior Pennsylvania caselaw on the retroactivity of new law in scenario number 1, the Court held that unless the appellate decision rendering the new law specifically states that it is to be applied prospectively, the new rule of law is to be applied retroactively to cases where the issue in question is properly preserved at all levels of adjudication, including any direct appeal.
Turning to the Dana Holding
case specifically, the Court held that the parties had preserved the constitutionality of the IRE provisions during the litigation of the initial Modification petition. The litigation involving the Modification Petition was ongoing at the time Protz
was issued. Thus, the Court held that the Protz
decision should be applied retroactively to the date of the IRE.
The issue of whether new law should be applied retroactively to final cases is still an open issue.
News & Information
Explore various types of trusts, including revocable, irrevocable, and testamentary, and discover their unique benefits. Learn how trusts can optimize estate planning, protect assets, and ensure tax efficiency.
Explore the intricacies of corporate governance in family-owned businesses, focusing on balancing family dynamics with strategic decision-making. Learn about succession planning, conflict resolution, and establishing formal governance structures.
Discover strategies to tackle common issues in insurance litigation. Learn about policy disputes, bad faith claims, and more, offering insights and practical solutions that Bingaman Hess offers to insurance carriers.
Explore the essentials of easements in property use, covering various types, creation methods, and termination processes. Stay informed on property rights and obligations for better real estate decision-making.
Explore the complexities of condemnation and eminent domain, focusing on property owner rights and municipal powers. Understand key legal processes, just compensation, and how public use impacts private property rights.
Discover the essential steps in managing and settling estates. Learn about the executor's role, handling debts and taxes, and the distribution of assets.
Explore the essential legal requirements for safeguarding corporate data and customer information. Learn about key regulations and how businesses can ensure compliance.
Explore the essentials of probate litigation, from understanding common disputes to navigating legal proceedings in estate administration. Gain insights into will contests, trust issues, and asset distribution to better handle probate conflicts.
Learn the essentials of drafting residential and commercial leases, focusing on key terms, negotiation strategies, and legal compliance. This guide ensures clear, legally sound agreements that protect landlords and tenants while fostering successful leasing relationships.
Explore the challenges of records management in compliance with Sunshine and Right-to-Know Laws. Learn about balancing transparency and privacy, handling high request volumes, and effectively overcoming technology and resource limitations.